Pilot · 11 min · 17 November 2026
AI Search Is the Biggest Change SEO Has Ever Seen
With Tom Critchlow and Jeremy Cabral
The pilot is Tom Critchlow and Jeremy Cabral alone in a New York studio on 1 November 2026. It runs eleven minutes and makes the case for the show, and for why anyone who works in search should be paying close attention right now.
Tom puts it plainly. If you're an SEO or you work in marketing, your job has turned upside down. Jeremy's answer is long-form conversation with the people doing the work, because nobody knows yet what comes next: MCPs, connectors, ChatGPT apps, or whether the web as we know it survives at all.
Three ideas run through every episode
Citation tracking is the first. Counting how often an LLM names you tells you about the past. Tom's argument is that you can now measure your brand's share of web directly, by crawling the information space around it.
Task gain is the second. Agents will find, book and decide for people, so the useful question shifts from what information a page adds to what task it helps complete.
Agent experience is the third. Can Muse book a ticket on your website? Jeremy expects agent experience scoring and benchmarking to become its own discipline, airlines first.
AI search is a brand question
Both hosts land in the same place. LLMs weigh a brand the way people do: price, offer and fit. That makes this brand marketing more than clicks and rankings, and it puts search people in the boardroom with a chance to lead. Jeremy calls AI search the Trojan horse for AI across the whole business.
The show records in New York, Sydney and San Francisco. Mike King and Josh Blyskal of Profound were the first guests booked.
Your hosts.

Tom Critchlow
Founder of the SEO MBA, search pioneer and industry thought leader. Tom has consulted on search for some of the world's biggest brands, including Google, The New York Times and Atlassian, and has helped over 1,000 SEO professionals with their careers.

Jeremy Cabral
Co-founder and former COO of Finder, Australia's largest affiliate. Jeremy scaled Finder to over 400 employees and more than $100m in revenue, and has coached hundreds of founders and executives on search transformations, content operations and digital strategy.
Key takeaways
The job flipped this year
Tom calls this the biggest change the search industry has seen. Anyone in SEO or marketing is doing a different job from the one they had two years ago.
Share of web is the better measure
Citation and recommendation rates in LLMs lag. Crawling the full information space around a brand measures what drives them.
Task gain replaces information gain
Agents act on people's behalf. The value of a page starts to depend on whether it helps finish a task, and that's what brands should measure.
Agent experience is the next audit
If an agent can't search and book on your site, it books somewhere else. Jeremy expects scoring and benchmarks for this, with airlines an obvious early case.
LLMs judge brands like people do
Price, offer and fit decide whether an agent picks you. Tom's view is that this sits closer to brand marketing than to technical SEO.
AI search leads into AI everywhere else
Jeremy's framing: discovery is the entry point, and the win is carrying the agent all the way through to a customer.
Chapters
- 0:00Cold open
- 0:56Why a long-form show
- 2:21Nobody knows what's next: MCPs, connectors and apps
- 2:56How Jeremy and Tom met: 25 days planning Finder's US launch
- 4:20Lifting people up while the industry reskills
- 5:30Idea one: citation tracking is a lagging indicator
- 6:02Idea two: from information gain to task gain
- 6:26Idea three: agent experience
- 6:53Search people are in the boardroom now
- 8:07Why an agent would care about your brand
- 9:20AI search is the way into AI
- 10:21Recording in New York, Sydney and San Francisco
Questions from this episode
What is the AI Search Leaders Podcast?
A long-form, filmed podcast from AI Search Leaders. Tom Critchlow and Jeremy Cabral talk to the people doing the work in AI search about what is changing and what to do about it.
Who hosts the AI Search Leaders Podcast?
Tom Critchlow and Jeremy Cabral, the founders of AI Search Leaders. They've worked together for over a decade, starting with Finder's launch in the US.
What are the three ideas behind the show?
Citation tracking is only part of the picture, so measure your brand's share of web. Agents complete tasks, so measure task gain. And your website has to work for agents, which Tom and Jeremy call agent experience.
What is share of web?
A measure of how much of the information space about your category talks about your brand, taken by crawling that space directly. Tom argues it's more accurate than citation rates in LLMs, which lag behind it.
What is agent experience?
Whether an AI agent can complete a task on your website, such as searching for and booking a flight. Jeremy expects it to be scored and benchmarked the way site speed is today.
Where is the podcast recorded?
In studios in New York, Sydney and San Francisco. The pilot and the first two guest episodes were recorded in New York on 1 November 2026.
Read the full transcript
0:00Tom Critchlow: This is the biggest transformation in the search industry than we've ever seen, right? I mean, not like across the entire society, but if you're an SEO professional or if you work in marketing, Your entire job is upside down right now. Is your website ready to be used by agents and LLMs? You think about, is your website accessible if Muse tries to go and book a ticket on your website? That's the conversation we need to be having. And a lot of the AI search conversation today is just not about that. It's about dumb metrics and short-term thinking and tactics. They're going to evaluate your brand on why do we care? Yeah. Right? And they're going to get the root of a matter of like, is the price better? Is the offer better? Right? Is it more suited to your needs? Like, why do we care? My take is that it's going to be a hard time for a lot of people in the industry that get left behind and try and cling to the old way of thinking. But it's never been a better time to be forward-looking. All right, welcome to the AI Search Leaders podcast. We booked a studio, we're here. Why are we doing this again, Jeremy?
1:00Jeremy Cabral: Yeah, well, I think podcast is key. Long form is where it's at. If you want to learn something new, you need to go immersion, like full, go deep on a topic. So yeah, big fan of that. I think that also with long form, you can do a lot of shorts as well. And people have those little snacks they need when they're learning something new. And what do people need to learn? Why are we here? Well, I mean, I think the industry is changing. We had a background, you and I, in traditional SEO for a very long time. But we're here to help people evolve with the industry and figure out what's next. I mean, let's be clear.
1:32Tom Critchlow: This is the biggest transformation in the search industry than we've ever seen, right? I mean, not like across the entire society, but if you're an SEO professional or if you work in marketing, your entire job is upside down right now. Totally.
1:45Jeremy Cabral: I mean, to even call it search is like everything in the other self. I mean, we only had the idea for this like back in, what, November last year or something. Right. But yeah, I think ultimately what we're talking about here is like wherever we come from, like what are we taking to the future? And how do we need to think to be relevant to build sustainable brands and businesses that can continue to use the web to drive acquisition and new customers? The highest level sense, right? Like I think there's lots of different models for the past, like clicks and traffic and all these sorts of things. And suddenly that's all out the window. Yep. And so what next, Tom?
2:21Tom Critchlow: Yeah, what next? I mean, that's why I'm excited for the podcast is nobody actually knows what's next, right? And so we've got to go speak to people, right? We've got to keep producing content. We've got to keep learning. We've got to stay curious. We're going to have some great people on the podcast like Mike King, Josh from Profound. We're gonna try and get some new voices on there as well, I think. The old guard isn't necessarily gonna cut it. We need fresh voices wherever it comes from. And we just gotta stay curious. Is it gonna be MCPs? Is it gonna be connectors? Is it gonna be like ChatGPT apps? Is the web dead? We've got some big questions to answer here.
2:54Jeremy Cabral: And it depends on the day of the week as well, right? Well, I think if I go back, man, like how I met you, I always benchmark myself globally. And that looked like being in the room with the best people. And I think that we were trying to build the room with AI Search Leaders that democratized our network and made it available for everybody that wasn't there 20 years ago at MozCon or whatever it was, like SearchLove, Distilled Conferences, and shout out to the team that built all these amazing things. As I was up and coming in the industry, I wanted to be like Right at the edge, like in the room, learning from the best. And when I was growing Finder globally, I remember I called you up and I was like, well, actually, I didn't call you up. I went to a conference, caught the attention of someone at the conference who knew you. And I was like, you're the top of my list of my guides. And so I reach out, you know, agree, like somehow to work with this crazy guy. And I roll into New York and then we spend 25 days in Airbnb, like pretty much unpacking Finder as a business. And figuring out how we're going to enter the US market and define a new playbook for what we're trying to do as a company. And I think that in a lot of ways, it's parallel to what we're trying to do here with AI Search Leaders. Really unpacking what we've learned thus far and trying to figure out what What's relevant?
4:09Jeremy Cabral: And how do we become not only like aware of what's important, but build entire teams around these functions and tooling, whatever it takes to be on the frontier. Yep.
4:20Tom Critchlow: And I mean, we've worked together for over a decade now, Jeremy, and I love working together. I love your energy. And one of the things I've always admired about you is you're always about lifting people up. Always, always, always. It's about taking somebody, spotting something that they have that's interesting, unique, valuable, and just lifting them up, right? And I think in this moment, A lot of people are stressed, confused, anxious, a lot of layoffs going on, right? Everyone needs to reskill. And I think that we have this kind of shared mission, right? Like how do we lift people up in this moment, right? How do we prepare them for the future? How do we help educate them on what is happening and why it's happening? And really just make sure that people are prepared. Because I think if you're flat-footed in this moment and you're not thinking
4:59Jeremy Cabral: about the future, I think AI Search Leaders first and foremost is a community, but it's also about a movement. It's about really trying to build awareness of a new method, a new way of thinking around things. I think with AI Search, unfortunately, it's overly simplified. The way that people talk about prompt tracking, I think that's enough. I just think the game is far more than that. I don't know if you want to share our thoughts, Tom, but we'll be jamming on this a little bit.
5:30Tom Critchlow: Right now, as of, you know, November 1st, 2026. But the first is like citation tracking isn't the whole game, right? And I think that what we believe is that you can actually track the share of web, right? You can actually crawl the web, the entire information And that's a much more accurate and valuable measure than citation and recommendation rate in the LLM, right? That's like a lagging indicator of what is the outcome of what do people say about your brand, right? But you can actually measure that much more Now, that's principle number one. Principle number two is we're gonna stop talking about information needs and information gain, and we're gonna talk about task needs and task gain, right? Agents are gonna do stuff for you, right? Found this podcast for me, right? They're gonna do things on your behalf and that's gonna radically change how we understand the value of information and brands across a customer journey. We should be measuring that and talking about that all day long. And a consequence of that, which is like a third principle is agent experience, right? Is your website ready to be used by agents and LLMs? You think about like, is your website accessible if Muse tries to go and book a ticket on your website? That's the conversation we need to be having. And a lot of the AI search conversation today is just not about that.
6:45Tom Critchlow: It's like about dumb metrics and short-term thinking and tactics. And I want to try and elevate above that and get to the real heart of like, this is a disruption for brands, right?
6:53Jeremy Cabral: It's a disruption for the industry. Exactly. And we've got the, like finally have that moment. We're in the actual boardroom, right? Like people are bringing us in. Executives want to hear from us. And we can't waste this opportunity. If you've got an SEO hat on, take it off. It's now a completely new game. And bring your skills from SEO. It's relevant. We need to train the new language models and everything about the past. But ultimately here, it's about A cross-disciplinary leader that can bring an organization forward. Someone that can really understand that it is a broad terrain, a broad number of sources that drive what we're talking about here. It's social, it's your reputation, it's the, as you mentioned, the ability I think agent experience scoring and benchmarking is going to become a thing. If you're an airline and you want to understand if somebody can complete a task on your website, searching flights, booking flights and so on, that's the stuff we need to look at. Starting from here, it's about Bringing people together, that's what AI Search Leaders is about. Sharing our knowledge, bringing knowledge from others, and from other spheres. We've been in such an isolated industry for such a long time, and we've got to learn from product managers, and technologists, Who else, man? There's so many people we've been talking about. Yeah, I mean, this is a brand question fundamentally, right?
8:09Tom Critchlow: It's like, we're going to have to measure it much more like brand marketing. We have to understand the customer journey and the customer funnel. We're going to have to understand positioning. Like, why does an agent give a crap about your brand is fundamentally much It's much more of a brand marketing thing than it is a clicks and ranking and technical discipline. It's like, LLMs are much more human than we give them credit for. They're gonna evaluate your brand on like, why do we care? And they're gonna get to the root of a matter of like, is the price better? Is the offer better? Is it more suited to your needs? Why do we care? That's fundamentally a brand question. My take is that it's gonna be a hard time for a lot of people in the industry that get left behind and try and cling to the old way of thinking, but it's never been a better time to be forward-looking. It's never been a better time to use this blend of creativity and data-driven, technical and executive focused, and bring that skillset together to be this cross-functional leader in this moment when so much of the world's economy is being poured into This is the future, right? And so I think that to be a leader in that space has never been a better time. Totally.
9:20Jeremy Cabral: AI Search Leaders is about taking everybody on the journey from where we are to zero clicks, no traffic, and then what next? I think that AI Search is a trojan horse into AI. What I mean by that is essentially, it's all well and great to have a brand that's turning up and discoverable, or separately in your business be efficient and effective with AI. But if you don't have this through line that takes the agent through to task completion, That's where it's at. That's how you win the customer initially in discovery and take it all the way through to continuing to work with your brand and choose your product and or service as the ultimate endgame of acquiring that customer ongoing. I think that's what this is about. We're bringing together who we know and meeting new people along the way as well. It's going to be a really fun journey building out this podcast with you. You've always been someone I've enjoyed building with. As I said, over a decade together doing this. So excited to see where we can take it together. We're going to record it in New York, Sydney, San Francisco. We're going to do a world tour. Absolutely. It's going to be great.
10:21Tom Critchlow: I'm excited to be here, Jeremy. It's so much fun. I mean, you know, we have this whole mission for the business, which is like helping people in the industry. It's also just a fun business to run together.
10:29Jeremy Cabral: That's it, man. It's vibes. Yeah. Let's go on this journey together. Let's go.
10:35Tom Critchlow: Boom. Thanks for listening to the show. This is the AI Search Leaders podcast. For more episodes, go to searchleaders.ai and like and subscribe to follow along.
Get the newsletter, too.
AI Search Leaders on Substack: Tom Critchlow on AI search and the people working it out, by email. Free.
Hear the show. Then join the room.
The podcast is free. Membership is the community, the expert sessions and the tools, with 150+ senior search people working out AI search together.